forest sunset landscape

25 June 2026 • 7 minute read

How wildfires spark criminal investigations and enforcement risk: Key considerations

Major wildfires have long carried legal consequences, but events over the past several years have demonstrated that legal risk can begin while the fire is still burning. Companies that may fare best are those with robust response plans already in place.

This alert provides an overview of key areas of legal exposure arising from wildfire events, including criminal liability, civil and regulatory risk, and related compliance considerations.

Overview

The Maui wildfire settlement and the Texas Attorney General’s Smokehouse Creek Fire lawsuit each underscore a different part of the same takeaway: Wildfire events could prompt criminal investigations, civil enforcement, cost-recovery actions, regulatory referrals, and fraud scrutiny before any court decides who, if anyone, is ultimately liable. A number of parties may be implicated in the event of a wildfire, including contractors, industrial operators, agricultural businesses, insurers, claims vendors, emergency suppliers, and companies with assets or personnel in the disaster zone.

Criminal and civil matters

Despite the speed and rigor that often characterize wildfire investigations, as well as ensuing press coverage and public pressure, criminal convictions of corporate actors remain relatively uncommon and uncertain in outcome. Following several major wildfires, including the 2017 Northern California wildfires, Woolsey Fire, Kincade Fire, and Zogg Fire, public authorities and courts have dismissed, settled, declined, or resolved matters short of conviction.

There have been some exceptions, including a California utility company’s guilty plea to 84 counts of involuntary manslaughter in connection with the 2018 Camp Fire, underscoring the severity of the risk in certain cases.

By contrast, on Maui, investigators concluded in the official origin-and-cause report that the 2023 fire was accidental and ruled out an intentional human act. However, a civil resolution of roughly $4 billion followed. Companies could face harm before determination of criminal liability and regardless of whether a conviction occurs. Search warrants, seized equipment, mandatory securities disclosures, parallel civil suits, and reputational damage could materialize while the question of criminal liability remains unresolved.

Even where criminal liability is established, it may not represent the primary area of exposure for companies. The 2018 Camp Fire provides an example: The responsible utility company agreed to a $3.5 million criminal fine as part of its criminal resolution, in addition to paying roughly $25.5 billion in wildfire settlements (including resolution of related civil suits) covering the Camp Fire and other 2017–2018 fires.

Additional liability considerations

From construction contractors to agricultural operators, any company whose equipment or operations could ignite a fire faces potential exposure. One California grading contractor paid $2.5 million to resolve federal claims after its equipment allegedly sparked a fire in a national forest. In a separate case, a federal jury returned a verdict of roughly $36 million against the contractors responsible for a fire one of them had negligently caused. These cases suggest that exposure follows the activity rather than the industry label.

Individual officers and managers can potentially face personal liability as well. Under the responsible-corporate-officer doctrine, certain federal environmental statutes, such as the Clean Air Act and Clean Water Act, can reach individuals who have authority to prevent a violation, even absent proof of personal knowledge. See 42 U.S.C. § 7413(c)(6); 33 U.S.C. § 1319(c)(6).

The United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit has likewise recognized that a person may qualify as a responsible corporate officer where the person has authority to exercise control over the corporate activity causing the violation. United States v. Iverson, 162 F.3d 1015 (9th Cir. 1998). To date, the doctrine has rarely been applied in wildfire prosecutions. However, state worker-safety agencies may be willing to investigate workplace fatalities and refer individual managers for criminal charges; this same mechanism does not foreclose application to wildfire cases.

Companies that are not traditionally prone to fires doing business in or near a disaster zone could also be at risk. Price-gouging statutes take effect automatically when a state of emergency is declared, capping increases on essential goods and services. Los Angeles-area wildfire-crimes task force materials show that enforcement resources can be quickly mobilized after an emergency declaration. Insurance claims handling and smoke-damage remediation may now draw heightened scrutiny of their own, as reflected in California’s Smoke Claims & Remediation Task Force. Additionally, the fraud task forces that form after a major fire are often broad in scope, potentially reaching vendors and contractors who have failed to adjust their ordinary practices for the emergency environment.

Proactive compliance considerations

A company that proactively builds response capabilities and deploys them immediately in the event of a wildfire may be best positioned to navigate subsequent investigations.

Legal and compliance counsel at companies with operations in fire-prone regions may consider five proactive steps:

  • Build and rehearse the crisis response plan. Defined roles, clear decision-making authority, and pre-established protocols can help legal, communications, and operations leadership in key operational steps – such as equipment shutdowns, site access, and coordination with first responders – before a fire occurs. A prepared holding statement may be valuable, but communications cannot outpace operations. A catastrophe creates an information vacuum, and silence rarely reads as caution; at the same time, premature or incomplete statements can create lasting exposure. These competing pressures may be best reconciled in advance.

  • Close the compliance gaps. Missed inspections, deferred maintenance, and unanswered regulatory notices may raise concerns for investigators, prompting a preliminary inquiry that could result in a full investigation and potential prosecution. Relevant company personnel may be well served to identify and resolve any gaps in advance of a crisis.

  • Establish evidence-preservation and first-72-hours protocols. Investigators typically move quickly to secure physical evidence and frame the official origin narrative. Once outside agencies hold the record, the company may be left responding to an emergency without the benefit of its own forensic analysis.

  • Plan for individual exposure. Consider the circumstances in which an officer or manager may need separate counsel and know which jurisdictions could assert authority over the company’s operations.

  • Audit disaster-zone business practices. Companies whose operations may touch an active disaster zone are encouraged to review pricing, contracting, and claims-handling procedures against the rules that activate the moment an emergency is declared.

Conclusion

Wildfire enforcement risk is not limited to the entity alleged to have caused the ignition. It could reach owners, operators, contractors, vendors, insurers, claims professionals, and individual managers as criminal investigators, regulators, and plaintiffs move in parallel.

Companies with operations, personnel, equipment, or customers in fire-prone regions are encouraged to consider the legal and compliance aspects of wildfire response readiness alongside emergency management.

DLA Piper’s Environmental and Catastrophic Events team and White Collar and Corporate Crime; Environment, Health, and Safety; and Insurance practices help clients assess exposure, preserve privilege, coordinate with enforcement agencies, and prepare for the first critical hours after ignition.

For more information about these issues, please contact the authors or your DLA Piper relationship partner.