
24 September 2026 • 7 minute read
DOJ revises Justice Manual to limit guidance-based FCA theories and broaden qui tam dismissal review
The United States Department of Justice (DOJ) recently announced revisions to the Justice Manual governing False Claims Act (FCA) matters.
The revision to Title 1 limits DOJ’s use of sub-regulatory guidance in litigation. The revision to Title 4 directs case-by-case assessments of whether to seek dismissal of declined qui tam actions, including reassessment as litigation progresses. DOJ’s Press Release No. 26-1081 links to both revised sections, 1-19.000 and 4-4.111.
DOJ presented the revisions on September 18, 2026 as advancing “fair and effective enforcement” by concentrating resources on cases grounded in binding statutory, regulatory, or contractual obligations, rather than on non-binding agency guidance.
Associate Attorney General Stanley E. Woodward, Jr. said in the release that “[t]he Department of Justice should enforce the law, not make law through enforcement.” Associate Deputy Attorney General Paul Perkins said the revisions “will help ensure the Department uses its enforcement authority fairly and effectively – holding fraudsters accountable for violations of binding legal or contractual obligations while seeking dismissal of meritless qui tam actions that waste taxpayer resources and impose unjustified burdens on businesses.”
In this alert, we detail the revisions and provide key takeaways.
Background
The FCA permits the Attorney General to sue for fraud against the government and allows private parties – relators – to file qui tam complaints on behalf of the US. DOJ attorneys consult the affected agency during investigation, litigation, and settlement. An agency may recommend dismissal, but the decision lies within DOJ’s exclusive authority.
Under 31 U.S.C. § 3730(c)(2)(A), the government may seek dismissal over a relator’s objection after notice and an opportunity for a hearing. In US ex rel. Polansky v. Executive Health Resources, Inc., 599 U.S. 419 (2023), the US Supreme Court held that the government may move to dismiss whenever it has intervened, but not if it never intervened; a court assesses the motion under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 41.
The constitutionality of the qui tam device itself remains in active litigation, though no such challenge has succeeded on appeal. On September 1, 2026, the US Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit rejected an Appointments Clause challenge in US ex rel. Zafirov v. Florida Medical Associates, LLC, No. 24-13581, while remanding the defendants’ Take Care Clause and Vesting Clause arguments. Those theories remain live on remand and are unaffected by the Justice Manual revisions, which are internal DOJ policy and do not speak to the statute’s constitutionality.
DOJ’s approach to sub-regulatory guidance has shifted with changes in leadership. This announcement reinstates a policy enacted in November 2017 by Attorney General Jefferson B. Sessions III, which provided that guidance may not substitute for rulemaking or impose new requirements on entities outside the Executive Branch. A January 2018 memorandum by then-Associate Attorney General Brand extended the principle to other agencies’ guidance in affirmative civil enforcement cases. Attorney General Merrick Garland rescinded both memoranda in July 2021, and Attorney General Pam Bondi began the current reinstatement in February 2025.
The revisions follow a record enforcement year. FCA settlements and judgments exceeded $6.8 billion in the fiscal year ending September 30, 2025, the highest single-year total in the statute’s history. Relators filed a record 1,297 qui tam actions, breaking the prior record of 980 set in 2024; the government opened 401 investigations; and cumulative recoveries since the 1986 amendments exceed $85 billion. Notably, roughly 43 percent of qui tam recoveries – about $2.3 billion – came from actions the government declined, up from about 12 percent the year before.
Justice Manual revisions
Title 1: Issuance and Use of Guidance Documents (1-19.000)
1-19.100 has carried DOJ’s guidance-issuance limits since 2018; the litigation-use limits now in 1-19.200 were previously in 1-20.000 until that section was removed in 2021. The revised text carries a September 2026 update stamp, and DOJ describes it as reinstating and building upon the 2017 policy.
1-19.100 provides that guidance may not substitute for regulation or impose new requirements on persons outside the Executive Branch “except as expressly authorized by law or contract.” Additionally, it states that DOJ components may not issue guidance purporting to create binding rights or obligations, or binding compliance standards, outside the Executive Branch.
1-19.210 provides that enforcement actions must be based on violations of applicable legal requirements – not mere noncompliance with guidance – and that DOJ may not bring actions based solely on noncompliance. The revised text nonetheless preserves guidance for evidentiary purposes consistent with the Federal Rules of Evidence, offering a non-exhaustive list of examples: scienter and notice, professional or industry standards, technical processes, a party’s own compliance, and legal or factual context. It cautions, however, that guidance carries no presumption of correctly stating the applicable standard and, like other evidence, may be contested or rebutted.
Title 4: DOJ Dismissal of a Civil Qui Tam Action (4-4.111)
4-4.111 has codified DOJ’s dismissal-factor policy that has been in place since September 2018 – when the agency incorporated the January 2018 Granston memorandum – and the seven factors carry forward unchanged. However, the September 2026 revision adds a directive that attorneys consider dismissal at the declination stage and revisit that assessment during litigation where they do not seek dismissal initially.
When evaluating a recommendation to decline intervention, attorneys will assess whether the government’s interests are served by seeking dismissal under Section 3730(c)(2)(A). Dismissal may not be warranted in every declined case because the government often investigates only to the point where declination is warranted – a conclusion that may not mean the action is meritless. Where DOJ declines to seek dismissal, it may re-evaluate as litigation progresses. A declination unaccompanied by a dismissal motion therefore leaves the question open.
The non-exhaustive factors include: meritless actions; parasitic or opportunistic actions duplicating a pre-existing government investigation; interference with agency policies or program administration; protecting DOJ litigation prerogatives; classified information or national security; preserving government resources where costs, including opportunity costs, are likely to exceed expected gain; and egregious procedural errors. Partial dismissal and alternative grounds – including the first-to-file bar, public disclosure bar, tax bar, or Rule 9(b) – remain available. Jointly handled cases require prior Assistant Attorney General approval; in delegated cases, dismissal authority generally rests with the US Attorney absent a novel issue of law or policy.
Scope
The operative criterion is the interest of the US. Defendant burden is not among the seven factors, each of which is framed around a government interest; therefore, submissions seeking dismissal are likely most effective framed in those terms.
Key takeaways
Liability must rest on a binding obligation, which narrows guidance-only theories. Enforcement must rest on violations of applicable legal requirements, not mere noncompliance with guidance. Defendants facing theories built on agency manuals now have a DOJ policy statement to invoke, though guidance remains available as evidence and the limit binds DOJ attorneys rather than courts.
Declination carries a paired dismissal assessment, but not a merits judgment. Attorneys must assess at declination whether dismissal serves the government’s interests, and may revisit that assessment as litigation progresses. With a record 1,297 filings and roughly 43 percent of Fiscal Year 2025 qui tam recoveries coming from declined actions, the assessment matters more as a channel for engagement than as a likely exit.
The Justice Manual binds DOJ attorneys, not relators. A declined qui tam prosecuted by private counsel is not directly governed by the guidance-use limits of 1-19.200, so persuading DOJ to act carries outsized value. DOJ attorneys may wish to advise relators of perceived deficiencies, which may offer a less costly exit than litigating a Rule 41 motion.
For more information, please contact the authors