Green_fluorite_stone_PPT

11 September 2026 • 9 minute read

New Zealand Court of Appeal provides class action guidance in natural disaster damage proceeding

In Toka Tū Ake – Natural Hazards Commission v Freer [2026] NZCA 396, the Court of Appeal has set aside representative orders for plaintiffs Andrew Freer and Lucinda McEvedy to bring proceedings against the Earthquake Commission (since renamed the Natural Hazards Commission) on behalf of residential land owners whose land suffered natural disaster damage (specifically, increased liquefaction vulnerability (ILV) damage) during the Canterbury Earthquake Sequence, and for whom EQC quantified settled their insurance claims based on diminution of value of the land (DOV) where the cost of reinstatement exceeded DOV.

While the proceeding relates to a bespoke statutory insurance scheme, it helpfully re-articulates existing principles of New Zealand’s class action jurisprudence:

  1. that representative plaintiffs’ claims must have sufficient merit so others can rely on them;
  2. that representative orders can proceed where common issues are sufficient to advance the interests of the class regardless of certain proof issues; and
  3. whether representative orders are appropriate in a proceeding will be intensely specific to both the factual and legal issues of any given case.

New Zealand remains a relatively plaintiff-friendly jurisdiction for class actions. The New Zealand courts seem less-likely to scrutinise the merits of a proceeding and nature of common issues with the same intensity as jurisdictions such as the United Kingdom would.

The New Zealand Law Commission recommended in 2022 that bespoke legislation should be introduced to standardise the procedural requirements relating to plaintiff class actions but this has not been progressed. You can read further about those recommendations here.

This case dealt with multiple issues about statutory insurance cover and representative orders, and the parties each pleaded different grounds of appeal. We set out the Court of Appeal’s findings on each of the issues below.

 

The plaintiffs did not have an arguable challenge to the High Court’s previous interpretation of the insurance cover under the EQC Act

In 2014, a full High Court bench (of three judges) held that under the EQC Act, natural disaster damage to residential land was covered on the basis of indemnity value. That judgment also held that the EQC’s policy for settling ILV and increased flooding vulnerability (IFV) claims on the basis of DOV where repair was not appropriate was consistent with the EQC Act (Full Court decision).

One proposed common issue in the representative order included whether claims for natural disaster damage to residential land are to be settled on an indemnity basis — wanting to challenge the Full Court decision. The plaintiffs argued they were instead entitled to the cost of reinstating their land up to the statutory cap, which was $160,000 in the circumstances. The High Court held that the plaintiffs’ interpretation of the EQC Act was not arguable and could not raise a significant common issue.

The Court of Appeal did not allow the plaintiffs’ appeal on this ground. The Court reiterated the general principle that an insurance policy is a contract of indemnity, and that the insured may recover no more than their actual loss (subject to any maximum amount recoverable). The relevant words of the EQC Act were analogous to a typical operative clause in an insurance policy – words would have to be read-in to the justify a departure from the general principle. The Court of Appeal also upheld the Full Court decision that the legislative history of the relevant sections supported the indemnity costs interpretation.

The Court of Appeal reiterated the Full Court’s statements that indemnity cover did not necessarily mean that a DOV payment was always the appropriate measure of loss. This is to be assessed on a case-by-case basis. It might sometimes be more appropriate to settle claims by meeting repair or reinstatement costs, but that would not always be the case.

 

Some of the common issues would materially advance the case, justifying representative orders

The Commission argued that the Associate Judge Paulsen in the High Court had failed to adequately consider whether a representative order would advance the objectives of securing the just, speedy and inexpensive determination of the proceedings. The Judge had to consider whether the common issues would materially advance the class members’ claims.

The Commission argued that the extent of proof required at stage two of the proceedings, after representative orders were made, would not advance the claims. It would be challenging for class members to establish the feasibility of repairing their individual IFV and ILV damage, to establish they had a claim. They would need to prove they intended to repair the land, had a feasible repair methodology, and that the cost of the proposed repair was not disproportionate to the DOV — the allegations as to EQC’s conduct could not establish the actual entitlement of any individual claimant.

The Court of Appeal disagreed. It held that, while class members must ultimately prove their individual entitlement, the Commission’s concerns could be sufficiently addressed by careful identification of the class and establishing subcategories. It analogised this case with Southern Response Earthquake Services Ltd v Southern Response Unresolved Claims Group [2017] NZCA 489, in which the Court of Appeal held that proceeding on the basis of the common issues would remove the need for multiple claimants to prove the correct interpretation of the same wording and whether essentially the same conduct amounted to a breach of contract. This was likely to enable prompt resolution of the claims and narrow the issues for subsequent proceedings or negotiations, despite stage two proof issues.

Additionally, the Court of Appeal said its conclusion that the statutory interpretation issue was not reasonably arguable meant the class must exclude homeowners who have sold their houses so would never incur the costs of repair anyway. This would remove a significant stage two proof issue.

 

The plaintiffs’ inability to undertake land repairs meant its claim lacked merit – the representative orders should be struck down

The Commission was successful in arguing that a claim which lacks merit (and so cannot succeed) will not be the subject of representative orders because it is not fair for other claims by members of the class rely on it. The Commission argued the plaintiffs were not adequate representatives of the proposed class because they were always unable to undertake repairs on their land, and therefore the High Court was wrong to see this as a trial issue. The plaintiffs could not be indemnified based on reinstatement or repair costs and were not adequate representatives of other class members (who could be indemnified on those bases).

In making an assessment of the merits, only a “broad-brush impressionistic” assessment is necessary, “rather than a detailed analysis of every allegation.” New Zealand Courts have historically been cautious that representative orders hearings do not turn into strike out applications by another name, so are often reluctant to engage in arguments on the substantive merits of a claim.

The Court of Appeal agreed with the Commission’s arguments and overturned the representative orders on this basis. The plaintiffs did want to repair their land but that depended on a satisfactory settlement with their private insurer. The proposed repairs involved a removal and rebuild of their house, which meant there was no realistic prospect of a land repair. Their inability to repair was unrelated to the Commission’s conduct but was rather a function of the options available to them at the time and the fact those options had not altered. This meant that there was no realistic prospect of land repair. Their claim lacked merit.

 

Other issues on appeal

The Court of Appeal went on to deal with the remaining grounds of appeal for completeness, despite its finding that the plaintiffs’ claim lacked merit. 

  • The plaintiffs’ claim about the Commission’s settlement policy was not time-barred: The Court of Appeal found that it was implicit in the plaintiffs’ first amended pleadings that the Commission’s settlement policy was under challenge. This meant the new pleadings in their second amended statement of claim, filed outside the primary limitation period, about the application of the policy did not amount to a fresh cause of action and were not time barred.
  • The plaintiffs had the same interest in relation to both ILV and IFV claims: The Court of Appeal said there was sufficient commonality between claims for ILV and IFV damage because the relevant sections of the EQC Act that formed the basis of the claim do not differentiate between types of natural disaster damage covered. The Commission also treated the two types of damage as functionally equivalent in how it applied its policy.
  • The third party proposed as an alternative IFV plaintiff was not suitable: The third party was not, and could not, become a party to the proceeding so could not become a representative plaintiff. He had not commenced an action in his own name and there was no application to join him as a party to the proceeding.
  • Some former land owners should be excluded from the class: The Court of Appeal held that, on ordinary principles of insurance law, the class could not include former owners who did not undertake repairs but retained their right to claim against the Commission, and subsequent owners who took an assignment of the right to claim against the Commission. The loss sustained was DOV in these cases.

 

Concluding thoughts

Though specific to the EQC Act context, this case restates and reinforces established legal principles relating to representative orders in New Zealand. Representative plaintiffs’ claims must have sufficient merit for others to be brought in on them, and common issues must efficiently advance a claim in order to meet the purposes of the rules relating to representative orders.

If you have any questions about representative orders and class actions in New Zealand, please do not hesitate to get in touch.