Iron_Gate_Gorge_PPT

9 July 2026 • 5 minute read

“Fidelity to the bargain” – the scope of express good faith obligations

Matière SAS (Matière) v ABM Precast Solutions Ltd (ABM)1 provides useful guidance on the interpretation of express good faith obligations in commercial contracts, whilst also demonstrating the difficulty of establishing causation for loss of opportunity. Good faith obligations are often a feature of contracts in the energy and natural resources sector and it is therefore critical to be clear as to their scope.

 

Key Takeaways

There is a significant evidential burden in establishing causation in a loss of chance claim. Even where a loss is proven, it must be established that the breaches, and not other factors, were the effective cause of the lost opportunity.

 

Matière SAS v ABM Precast Solutions Ltd

Background

The dispute arose from the parties’ joint bid for a subcontract with a joint venture (EKJV) between Eiffage Genie Civil and Kier Infrastructure and Overseas Ltd (Kier), for the Green Tunnels Project under the HS2 rail scheme. The parties agreed that Matière would be responsible for the design and installation of the tunnels, which would be manufactured by ABM. Matière and ABM entered into a Consortium Agreement in January 2019 and a more sophisticated Collaboration Agreement in June 2020, for the purpose of preparing and submitting their bid. Both agreements contained express good faith obligations.

ABM’s proposal was to manufacture precast concrete tunnel components at a new permanent factory. EKJV appointed Matière/ABM as its strategic partner under a professional services contract. However, EVJV later terminated this contract and instead contracted directly with Matière for its installation work.

Matière initially sued ABM for sums due under the Consortium Agreement2. ABM counterclaimed on the basis that Matière breached the general obligations of good faith that were expressly set out in both the Consortium Agreement and Collaboration Agreement by: (i) undermining ABM’s proposal to build a new factory to manufacture the tunnels; and (ii) assisting with investigations into alternatives without ABM’s knowledge. ABM claimed damages of nearly GBP19 million for loss of earnings and on account of profits made by Matière’s entry into its contract with EKJV.

Good faith

In determining whether Matière had breached the express good faith obligations in both the Consortium Agreement and the later Collaboration Agreement, the Judge examined the scope of the duty of good faith, noting that at its core, good faith requires the parties to “act honestly”, but that also “bad faith may include conduct which would be regarded as commercially unacceptable to reasonable and honest people, even if not necessarily dishonest”.

In interpreting the clauses, the court applied the principles in Re Compound Photonics Group Ltd3, which highlighted the importance of interpreting good faith clauses in line with the context and the “spirit of the agreement ”. The Judge in Matière v ABM considered that a key consideration in this assessment should be “whether the action complained of might, at the time, be expected to render the contract worthless or less valuable”.

Applying these principles, the Court held that Matière had breached its good faith obligations to ABM by outwardly supporting ABM but privately undermining the joint bid through unilateral communications with EKJV. The Judge held that Matière’s actions “were on occasion either dishonest or was of a type that would be regarded as commercially unacceptable to reasonable and honest people” and it “did not keep fidelity to the bargain it made with ABM and its actions had the potential to render that bargain worthless or significantly less valuable”. Accordingly, the Judge ruled that there had been breaches of the express good faith obligations in respect of both agreements.

Good faith claim failed on causation

Despite the Court accepting that Matière breached its obligations of good faith, ABM’s counterclaim  failed on causation because ABM:

  • failed to prove on the balance of probabilities that it had a real or substantial chance of securing the HS2 contract; and
  • failed to prove on the balance of probabilities that the breach was causative of that loss of chance by showing that the breach was the effective or dominant cause of that loss of chance.

On that basis, it was held that Matière’s conduct in breaching its good faith obligations was not the dominant cause of ABM’s loss of chance to win the bid.

 

Why is it significant?

This decision demonstrates that, when interpreting such obligations and assessing whether they have been breached, the Court will place significant weight on the commercial reality underpinning the parties’ aims and objectives.

 


1 Matière SAS v ABM Precast Solutions Ltd [2025] EWHC 1434 (TCC) T
2 As Matiére's claim is not the focus of this analysis, it is not addressed further. However, for completeness, the court allowed Matière’s claim for GBP373,295.06 in full. ABM ultimately admitted most of the invoiced sum and only disputed about GBP35,000 but failed to substantiate the alleged discrepancy. Given the late admissions and absence of evidence isolating any overstatement, it was held that Matière discharged the burden of proof and all invoices were held payable.
3 [2022] EWCA Civ 1371

Contacts