Turquoise_water_PPT

9 July 2026 • 5 minute read

Funding Opens Door for Brazil Iron Claims in English Courts

The energy and natural resources sector is a hotbed for class actions. Claims arising from overseas operations are allowed to proceed in England where there is a real risk that claimants cannot obtain substantial justice in the natural foreign forum.

In Catarina Oliveira da Silva and Others v Brazil Iron Limited and Another, the Court accepted jurisdiction over environmental claims connected to Brazil, placing renewed emphasis on access to litigation funding as a decisive factor in forum challenges.

 

Key takeaways
  • Brazil was the natural forum for the dispute, but England nevertheless retained jurisdiction on the basis of a real risk that the claimants could not obtain substantial justice in Brazil.
  • Difficulties in securing litigation funding and legal representation in the foreign forum can amount to “special circumstances” under the Spiliada Maritime Corporation v Cansulex Ltd (Spiliada) jurisdiction test, which determines whether England has jurisdiction.
  • Undertakings offered by defendants to fund disbursements are unlikely to cure concerns where they risk conflicts of interest or do not address the overall economic viability of the claim.
  • The decision continues a line of authority in which English courts permit claims with significant foreign elements to proceed where access to justice would otherwise be compromised.

 

Background

The claims were brought by 103 Brazilian nationals, including members of the Quilombola community, in relation to alleged environmental harm caused by pollution from an iron ore mine in Brazil. The mine was owned and operated by a Brazilian subsidiary, which the claimants alleged acted under the control and direction of two companies domiciled in England.

The claimants alleged that the mine caused environmental damage to their land, physical damage to property, and air and noise pollution, and harassment and intimidation by individuals connected with the mine. Proceedings were commenced in England against the UK-domiciled parent companies.

The defendants challenged the English court’s jurisdiction, arguing that Brazil was clearly the more appropriate forum for the dispute. The challenge was determined by reference to the two-stage test in Spiliada, which applies where a defendant has been served within the jurisdiction.

 

The High Court’s approach to jurisdiction

Stage one: Brazil as the natural forum

At the first stage of the Spiliada analysis, the Court agreed with the defendants that Brazil was the forum with the most real and substantial connection to the claims. The alleged pollution occurred in Brazil, Brazilian law and regulatory frameworks applied, and the claimants and most witnesses were based in Brazil and spoke Portuguese.

The Court also noted that the claims were likely to involve nuanced cultural and social issues, including the status of the Quilombola people, with which an English court would be unfamiliar. Convenience, cost, and the location of documentary and witness evidence all pointed towards Brazil as the natural forum.

Stage two: risk to substantial justice

The Court went on to consider whether, despite its conclusion that Brazil was the natural forum, there were “special circumstances” such that justice nevertheless required the claims to proceed in England. The Court held that there was evidence of a real risk that the claimants would not be able to obtain substantial justice if the claims were pursued in Brazil.

Central to this finding were the difficulties the claimants faced in securing funding and legal representation. The claimants were of limited means and they could not fund the litigation themselves. The claims were complex, would require extensive expert evidence, and were likely to take years to resolve. The individual value of each claim was relatively modest, making the economics of litigation unattractive for prospective lawyers in Brazil.

Although conditional fee arrangements and other forms of deferred fee agreements were available in Brazil, these were insufficient to overcome the funding difficulties. The capped and damages-based nature of such arrangements, combined with the scale and complexity of the claims, meant there was a real risk that no suitable legal representation could be secured.

The defendants offered undertakings to submit to Brazilian jurisdiction and to fund certain disbursements, including expert costs. The Court rejected these proposals, noting that they risked conflicts of interest. They did not address the underlying question of whether the claims were economically viable to run in Brazil.

By contrast, the claimants had been able to obtain representation in England on a “no win, no fee” basis, with additional litigation costs capable of being funded. On that basis, the Court concluded that this dispute was one of the exceptional cases in which the inability to secure representation in the foreign forum justified the English court retaining jurisdiction.

 

Implications for UK-based companies with overseas operations

For UK-based companies with overseas operations, the decision reinforces the risk that claims connected to foreign activities may still be litigated in England, even where another forum has a closer factual and legal connection. Funding and access to justice considerations can play a decisive role in jurisdictional challenges, particularly in group environmental or human rights claims involving claimants of limited means.

Defendants should be cautious about assuming that undertakings to fund disbursements will be sufficient to defeat arguments based on access to justice. Early assessment of potential jurisdictional exposure, group claim dynamics, and funding arguments is likely to be critical when disputes of this nature arise.

 

Conclusion

Catarina Oliveira da Silva and Others v Brazil Iron Limited and Another illustrates the English Court’s willingness to accept jurisdiction in exceptional cases where access to justice would otherwise be at risk. Although Brazil was plainly the natural forum, the Court’s focus on funding and representation proved decisive.

For businesses operating internationally, the judgment underscores the importance of understanding how jurisdiction, group claims, and litigation funding intersect. Access to justice considerations are likely to remain a powerful factor in future forum challenges involving environmental and human rights allegations.

Contacts