
10 June 2026 • 2 minute read
The Dutch Court of Appeal clarifies entitlement of taxpayers to late payment interest in case of VAT repayment claims
A Dutch company (X) sold goods to private individuals in Belgium over the course of several years (2015 to 2018). Under EU distance sales rules, the place of supply was deemed to be Belgium, meaning Belgian VAT was due. However, X erroneously charged and remitted Dutch VAT for these supplies instead.
The Dutch tax authorities ("DTA") agreed to repay the wrongly remitted VAT amounts for the years 2015-2018 but refused X's claim for late-payment interest for that same period. According to the DTA no interest was owed to X because the VAT repayment claim resulted from X's own error.
According to X, the Dutch tax authorities were obliged to pay late payment interest because X overpaid VAT amounts in the years 2015–2018 in violation of EU law. It is not relevant which party is responsible for the erroneous payment of VAT.
The Court of Appeal agreed with the position of the DTA and referred to the CJEU's judgment in the Dinkelland case. The CJEU held that no recovery interest arises where there is no breach of EU law on the part of the tax authority. In the Dinkelland case, the taxable person had erroneously failed to exercise its right of deduction meaning that the repayment claim arose due to an error on the part of the taxpayer. The Court of Appeal found no meaningful distinction between the Dinkkelland case and the repayment claim of X and therefore denied the claim of X for payment of late payment interest.
Key takeaway / recommendation
In recent years, Dutch courts have issued multiple judgements on late payment interest imposed by the DTA on taxpayers for unpaid tax liabilities. This judgement from the Court of Appeal is interesting as it provides clarity on whether interest must be paid to taxpayers in case of a VAT repayment claim. The Court of Appeal made it very clear that taxpayers are not eligible for late-payment interest if a VAT refund claim results from an error on the part of a taxpayer.
Reference
ECLI:NL:GHSHE:2026:1130, Gerechtshof 's-Hertogenbosch, 24/1535 tot en met 24/1544 en 26/486
