
10 June 2026 • 2 minute read
TP adjustments and consideration for a VAT taxable supply
In Stellantis Portugal (Case C‑603/24, 13 May 2026), the CJEU held that transfer pricing adjustments made under an intra-group agreement to maintain a target margin for a vehicle distributor were not on the facts consideration for repair services allegedly supplied to the Original Equipment Manufacturers (OEMs). The Court applied the established “direct link” test and found it was not satisfied: (i) no contractual obligation existed for the distributor to supply repair services to the OEMs — the only legal relationship concerned vehicle pricing; (ii) the margin adjustment reflected the distributor’s entire operating cost base, not solely warranty repairs, making any connection indirect; and (iii) the bi-directional, contingent nature of the adjustments meant remuneration was uncertain. The ruling confirms that TP profit allocation mechanisms do not, in themselves, create separate VAT taxable transactions. However, where a contract establishes reciprocal obligations for services in exchange for adjustments, a different analysis may apply. Importantly, TP adjustments may still modify the taxable base of identifiable underlying supplies, requiring VAT corrections.
Key takeaway / recommendation
Multinational groups should review their intra-group agreements to ensure that TP adjustment mechanisms are clearly documented as price recalibrations for existing supplies, rather than consideration for separate services. The judgment provides strong support for taxpayers in ongoing disputes where authorities seek to recharacterise TP adjustments as consideration for taxable supplies. Contact us to discuss the implications for your group’s arrangements.
Reference
Case C‑603/24, Stellantis Portugal (CJEU, 13 May 2026)
