
18 November 2026 • 3 minute read
EEOC rescinds enforcement guidance on use of arrest and conviction records in employment decisions
On October 28, 2026, the United States Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) rescinded its 2012 Enforcement Guidance on the Consideration of Arrest and Conviction Records in Employment Decisions Under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 (Guidance), effective immediately. The Guidance recommended a role-specific approach to criminal history screening that considered the nature and seriousness of an offense, the time elapsed since the offense or completion of a sentence, and the nature of the role held or sought.
The withdrawal does not change employers’ underlying obligations under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 (Title VII). Discrimination based on race or national origin is still prohibited, and facially neutral criminal history policies may still face disparate impact challenges – which require no proof of discriminatory intent – where they disproportionately exclude members of a protected group and cannot be shown to be job-related and consistent with business necessity.
Although the EEOC directed its staff in 2025 to no longer pursue or investigate cases in which the only allegation is disparate impact, that directive did not change the underlying case law. Private plaintiffs and state and local agencies remain free to bring such claims. The EEOC has also made clear that employers are not required to discontinue lawful practices adopted in response to the former Guidance.
Arrest records
The Guidance distinguished between arrests and convictions. Because an arrest does not establish that a person engaged in criminal conduct, the Guidance stated that excluding an individual based solely on an arrest record would not meet Title VII’s standard of being job-related and consistent with business necessity. However, employers could consider the conduct underlying the arrest if that conduct made the individual unfit for the role.
That distinction remains relevant after the rescission. Arrest-based screening may be subject to disparate impact claims, and an arrest that did not result in a conviction may be difficult to defend as a basis for an employment decision.
Many state and local laws also independently restrict the use of arrest records. For example, California and Philadelphia prohibit consideration of arrests that did not result in a conviction; Washington State bars adverse action based on arrest records other than pending charges; and New York City requires a written, individualized assessment and an opportunity to respond, including for pending cases.
Key considerations
Employers may wish to evaluate whether any changes to criminal history exclusions are appropriate following the withdrawal. They may also consider reviewing existing screening policies to confirm that criteria remain relevant to the role, are applied consistently, and comply with other applicable requirements, including state and local fair-chance and “ban the box” laws and, where third-party background reports are used, the Fair Credit Reporting Act.
With respect to arrest records, employers may wish to review how their policies address pending charges and arrests that did not result in a conviction, including whether they use an individualized assessment that considers the nature of the alleged conduct, its relevance to the position, and any information the individual provides.
Consistent application of written criteria and documentation of screening decisions may support employers’ compliance and risk-management efforts related to both individual discrimination claims and disparate impact claims.
For more information, please contact the authors or your DLA Piper relationship partner.