Green_bottles_S_2184-4K2

10 November 2026 • 12 minute read

EPR across North America: Legal and practical challenges for producers in Canada, the United States, and Mexico

Extended producer responsibility (EPR) regulatory regimes are reshaping the landscape for products and packaging across North America. At its core, EPR shifts financial and operational responsibility for managing products and packaging at end of life – from collection and recycling to disposal – away from governments and consumers and onto producers, often through mandatory participation in producer responsibility organizations (PROs) and fee structures tied to material type, volume, and recyclability.

While EPR laws were once limited in scope and geographic reach, they have evolved into a complex collection of statutes, regulations, and market-based mechanisms that differ across Canada, the United States, and Mexico. For producers operating across borders, these differences can result in material compliance, cost, and operational challenges, particularly as EPR programs move from legislative adoption to implementation and enforcement.

This alert examines the current state of EPR across North America and highlights legal and practical considerations for producers navigating cross-border supply chains.

Canada: EPR implementation and challenges

Canada remains the most mature EPR market in North America, with several provinces having transitioned from cost-sharing models to fully producer-operated systems. Ontario completed the transition of its Blue Box program for packaging to a producer-run framework at the end of 2025, making producers of packaging composed of paper, glass, metal, plastic, or a combination of those materials responsible for collection, processing, and consumer education obligations across the province. British Columbia continues to operate the continent's longest-standing full EPR program for packaging and paper products through Recycle BC, with a renewed program plan emphasizing harmonized material acceptance, collection access, and end-market sustainability consistent with the province’s pollution prevention hierarchy, which prioritizes source reduction and reuse over recycling and disposal.

Developments in Québec illustrate both program scale and operational complexity. One year after the expansion of the province's deposit-return system to include plastic beverage containers, return volumes exceeded 750 million containers, reflecting strong public participation and continued expansion of collection infrastructure. The program is scheduled to expand further by March 2027 to include glass and multi-layer carton containers, underscoring the pace at which Canadian programs are broadening the scope of materials covered.

Beyond its deposit-return system, Québec has seen key developments in its EPR framework over the past year and a half. On January 1, 2025, the province launched a modernized curbside recycling system for containers, packaging, and printed paper. It also expanded its EPR regime to cover ready-to-drink beverage containers of up to two liters. The rollout for containers made of glass, other breakable materials, or fibers, including multi-layer containers, was postponed until March 1, 2027. To assist small and medium-sized businesses in addressing the effects of EPR, Québec announced CAD27 million in transitional financial assistance for eligible producers in early 2026. 

Alberta began its transition to both packaging EPR and hazardous and special-products EPR on April 1, 2025. The first phase covered residential dwellings that received recycling services before the launch of the EPR program. The second phase of packaging EPR rolled out to the remaining residential dwellings on October 1, 2026.

Despite this maturity, Canadian EPR programs face ongoing challenges, including responsible end-market capacity, verification of downstream recycling outcomes, and the treatment of non-standard packaging formats that fall outside conventional residential collection systems. 

US: State-by-state adoption, litigation, and national frameworks

Seven states – California, Colorado, Maine, Maryland, Minnesota, Oregon, and Washington – have enacted packaging EPR laws, but program architecture varies by jurisdiction. States differ in how they define “producer”; allocate responsibility among brand owners, importers, and distributors; and structure performance and reporting obligations. As these programs move from legislative adoption into implementation, PROs play a central role in translating statutory mandates into operational compliance frameworks, with varying levels of infrastructure readiness across states.

One feature of the US landscape is increasing regulatory focus on responsible end markets to support downstream demand and verifiable processing. Several state packaging EPR laws address whether collected material reaches responsible or otherwise qualifying end markets, although terminology and compliance mechanisms vary.While intended to address long‑standing concerns about recycling integrity, these programs raise questions regarding the verification of materials processed outside the US, particularly where collected materials are transported across borders for recycling or end-market processing. 

State EPR laws also focus on packaging design. Many programs implement eco-modulation principles and require producer fees to vary based on factors such as recyclability, material choice, recycled content, and other environmental attributes. California’s Plastic Pollution Prevention and Packaging Producer Responsibility Act, also known as SB 54, combines this approach with progressively stricter recyclability and plastic source-reduction requirements. These measures may require producers to fund end-of-life management and change the materials and packaging formats they place on the market. In more recent news, CalRecycle received the PRO’s producer responsibility plan on October 13, 2026, and opened a public comment period through November 13, 2026 while the agency conducts its statutory compliance review.

State EPR programs also face an evolving litigation landscape in the US. The first ruling on the constitutional merits in litigation challenging a state EPR law came on August 27, 2026 when the US District Court for the District of Oregon upheld Oregon’s Recycling Modernization Act in National Association of Wholesaler-Distributors v. Feldon, rejecting Dormant Commerce Clause and Due Process Clause challenges after a five-day bench trial. The decision, as it stands, provides an early judicial assessment of a state EPR framework while challenges to Colorado’s and California’s programs proceed in separate courts. The National Association of Wholesaler-Distributors (NAW), however, initiated an appeal to the US Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit on September 24, 2026, and have subsequently sought a stay pending appeal. A Ninth Circuit ruling would be the first by a US Court of Appeals on the constitutional merits of a state’s packaging EPR law and would establish binding precedent within the Ninth Circuit, including in California, Oregon, and Washington. NAW has also challenged packaging EPR in federal court in California, where the organization is joined by a coalition of 17 state attorneys general, and in Colorado, where a separate challenge by the Independent Lubricant Manufacturers Association is pending in state court.

At the same time, environmental groups have sued CalRecycle, arguing that the regulations implementing SB 54 are too permissive because they leave open the possibility that pyrolysis related to chemical (or "advanced" recycling) could count toward recycling targets. Two industry groups recently intervened to defend those rules.

Mexico: Lifecycle responsibility embedded in federal law with varied implementation

Mexico’s federal legal framework expressly recognizes the principle of EPR as a subset of the broader principle of shared responsibility (responsabilidad compartida). Key statutes are the General Law on the Prevention and Comprehensive Management of Wastes, its regulations, and the General Law on Circular Economy. The first two categorize waste streams into three main categories and allocate primary jurisdiction over each category to the federal, state, or municipal level of government. They also distribute responsibility for waste prevention, collection, management, reuse, and recovery across the product lifecycle among producers, distributors, consumers, and government authorities, rather than placing exclusive end‑of‑life obligations on producers.

Following entry into force of the General Law on Circular Economy on January 20, 2026, the concept of EPR has gained increased relevance in Mexico. However, several regulatory and technical provisions necessary for full implementation remain pending, including the law’s regulations. The law provided a 180-calendar-day period for issuance of those regulations, and that deadline has passed. The law also gave each of Mexico’s 32 states 180 calendar days to adapt and harmonize their respective legislation, and that deadline has likewise passed. Compliance with that mandate remains uneven, particularly because many of the most relevant EPR-related waste streams fall under state-level jurisdiction. In practice, EPR principles have been implemented primarily through federal framework laws combined with state or municipal waste-management statutes of limited and varying scope and enforcement, rather than through a unified, producer-run compliance system. As a result, producers do not generally face standardized registration, fee‑setting, or recovery target obligations for packaging comparable to those imposed under Canadian provincial regimes or US state EPR laws. This has contributed to an overall regulatory landscape that reflects comprehensive EPR principles but remains operationally fragmented and presents implementation challenges, even as it introduces avenues for increasing regulatory compliance and enforcement.

Comparative legal and practical challenges

While EPR programs share basic principles, differences among EPR frameworks in Canada, the US, and Mexico can create challenges for producers operating in North America. Variations in the definition of “producer,” covered materials, reporting metrics, enforcement mechanisms, and fee structures mean that the same product or package can trigger materially different obligations depending on the jurisdiction in which it is sold, shipped, or imported.

1. Trade-related implications and market access considerations

Although EPR laws are generally framed as environmental and waste management measures, divergent compliance requirements, such as jurisdiction-specific labeling mandates, recyclability standards, or end-market verification rules, can pose barriers to market access. For example, performance-based recyclability requirements or responsible end-market standards could effectively disadvantage packaging formats or materials commonly used in cross-border trade when sufficient downstream infrastructure is unavailable in a particular jurisdiction.

As EPR programs increasingly embed design mandates, fee modulation tied to packaging design and material selection, and downstream processing verification, regulators could also scrutinize where recycled materials are processed and under what conditions. These dynamics raise questions about how far a jurisdiction’s EPR authority can extend beyond its borders, particularly when collection occurs in one country but recycling or end-market processing occurs in another. Although no formal trade disputes have yet arisen from EPR laws in North America, continued divergence could result in challenges grounded in trade agreements or domestic constitutional principles.

2. Operational compliance considerations for multinational producers

For international companies, EPR compliance is less a single programmatic obligation than a continuous exercise in jurisdictional mapping and operational coordination. Multinational producers must determine their obligations across jurisdictions, including identifying which entity is responsible as the producer and which jurisdiction’s laws apply. This determination can be complex for companies with multi-layered supply chains involving brand owners, importers, distributors, and online marketplaces. The applicable requirements can differ not only among countries but also among US states, Canadian provinces, and Mexican states.

Data management could present another cross-border challenge. EPR programs often rely on jurisdiction-specific reporting of material weights, formats, and sales volumes, using distinct calculation methods and audit expectations. For companies selling the same products across North America, aligning internal data systems to meet differing reporting requirements may be resource-intensive and require product-level tracking beyond traditional supply chain visibility.

3. Non-standard packaging and fragmented coverage

EPR programs across North America largely remain focused on household packaging and consumer facing products. Industrial, transport, and non-standard packaging formats – such as pallets, gas cylinders, and mixed-material and large-format transit packaging – are sometimes excluded or treated inconsistently, even when such packaging moves across borders. Companies relying on non-standard packaging formats that remain unregulated may address end-of-life management through concurrent contractual arrangements or voluntary take-back programs, which can increase complexity and cost.

This fragmentation is particularly relevant for cross-border manufacturing and distribution models in which packaging may be introduced into the market in one jurisdiction, reused or distributed in another, and disposed of in a third. In the absence of harmonized EPR rules, producers bear the burden of reconciling overlapping or incomplete regulatory regimes.

Looking ahead

Formal harmonization of EPR laws across North America has not occurred, but regulatory and operational developments may lead to partial convergence. PRO-driven alignment efforts, shared verification standards for downstream recycling, and federal involvement in specific product streams, such as batteries, could incrementally narrow compliance differences. At the same time, litigation and constitutional challenges in the US highlight legal questions associated with EPR programs that affect interstate and cross-border commerce.

Practical considerations for affected businesses

The following considerations may be relevant to producers and in-house counsel managing operational and legal issues arising from EPR requirements across Canada, the US, and Mexico. 

  • Cross-border compliance mapping. Identifying which legal entity qualifies as the producer is a key step because definitions differ among US states, Canadian provinces, and Mexican states. Supply chains involving brand owners, importers, distributors, online marketplaces, and co-packers may further affect that determination.

  • Packaging data management. Companies should consider standardizing their approaches to capturing and maintaining data on material weights, formats, and sales volumes across their North American operations, while preserving jurisdiction-specific calculations required by the relevant jurisdictions’ EPR programs.

  • Design and source-reduction mandates. Companies may wish to incorporate EPR requirements into packaging design and procurement reviews. California’s SB 54 is currently the only US packaging EPR law that requires reductions in plastic packaging placed on the market, and eco-modulation penalties can apply to labels, sleeves, valves, nozzles, coatings, adhesives, and certain additives. Design decisions made today may affect fee exposure for years to come.

  • Mexico’s evolving circular-economy framework. Federal regulations and state-level measures are expected to further define how the General Law on Circular Economy operates in practice. Because many relevant waste streams fall under state jurisdiction, compliance obligations may vary among states rather than being governed by a single national framework.

  • Non-standard and industrial packaging. Pallets, gas cylinders, and large-format transit packaging are frequently excluded or treated inconsistently under EPR regimes. Companies are encouraged to consider the costs and benefits of end-of-life management through supplier and customer agreements or voluntary take-back programs where regulatory coverage is unclear.

  • Ongoing litigation developments. Companies may wish to track the Ninth Circuit appeal in National Association of Wholesaler-Distributors v. Feldon, the 17-state coalition and NAW challenge to California’s SB 54, the actions brought in Colorado state and federal court challenge, and the environmental non-governmental organization's suit against CalRecycle concerning chemical recycling. Because these matters could affect the implementation, timing, or interpretation of applicable requirements, companies are encouraged to closely monitor developments and maintain adaptable compliance plans.

DLA Piper’s Sustainability practice continues to monitor developments in EPR regulation and litigation across North America and their potential implications across industries. If you have questions regarding EPR laws, please contact any of the authors. Additional information is available on DLA Piper’s Extended Producer Responsibility (EPR) Requirements topic hub.